Are Index Funds Secure: The Truth About Index Funds, And Why You Might Want To Invest in Them

Some investors operate under the assumption that fund managers cannot or will not outperform the market. Therefore, to minimize fees, these investors use a strategy called index investing, which involves creating portfolios around market averages, benchmarks, or stock indexes, such as the S&P 500. While some savvy investors make the most of index funds, most people believe these options are too risky for the average investor and point to several reasons they are a bad idea.

What Are Index Funds?

An index fund is typically comprised of various ETFs and mutual funds. The funds are then compiled into a broad portfolio that is designed to mimic a specific index. An index fund can provide broad market exposure, low portfolio turnover, and low operating expenses if created well. The highlight of these funds and their ultimate goal is to provide a more stable investment strategy regardless of the state of the market. Unfortunately, these funds are not always as fool-proof as fund managers would like you to believe.

Benefits of Index Funds

Ideally, index investing is a form of passive investing, and it is meant to follow market or index patterns. Therefore, when the market or index is doing well, your investments are also performing accordingly.

The primary benefit of an index fund is its lower cost. Managed funds have a significantly higher expense ratio. The reason for the lower price is the automated nature of index funds. You do not have the underlying expenses, such as transaction fees, accounting fees, taxes, advisor and manager payments.

Another advantage of index funds is the built-in diversification of your portfolio. These investment options require that the portfolios match the variety of the market or index it is meant to mimic, meaning investors gain access to the same diverse field.

Finally, index funds are best for long-term gains or buy-and-hold investors. Index investing is also ideal for retirement funds, like IRAs. 

[insert page='Offer' display='content']

Drawbacks of Index Funds

Consequently, index funds are not suitable for short-term investors or those who like to be hands-on with their portfolios. Because of the lack of a human element, investors will experience less flexibility. Additionally, as a long-term asset, an index fund will only provide limited gains for short-term investors.

However, the primary drawback of index funds is their ultimate vulnerability. Since the funds mimic specific indexes or markets, they are also sensitive to crashes and market swings. Meaning, if you are after stability and secure returns, index options might not be the best fit for you or your investment strategy.

Index Fund Expectations

If you invest in an index fund, you must maintain realistic expectations. The fund will likely never outperform the market because it is not designed to do so. Instead, it is designed to match or mimic market performance.

If you are interested in outperforming the market, you need to focus on high-risk alternatives. You might also want to consider working with a professional who understands financial analysis and market behavior.

Ultimately, whether an index fund is right for you depends on your investment strategy and style. For passive investors who appreciate the long hold, an index fund could work, but index funds are too risky and likely disappointing for those interested in beating the market.

What is your preference? Leave a comment below.